They were 2 good sizes in there but as a first t8me purchaser i didnt realize how heavy they are, so 1lb its a lot. I also realize i dont think my dog can do heavy chewer. One of the antlers had the horn so it ws perfect fod her the other too bulky she couldnt chew. Overall they re antlers and i really think sje wanted to chew it. So i will be purchases different onces know to try. I can say the other antker part that came with is being enjoyed by another family dog so no wasting.